FictionLiterary FictionShort Stories

Have This Heart
by Lawrence Patchett

A compassionate story collection of 'gentle humanity'

By November 18, 2026No Comments
Advertisement

Lawrence Patchett’s second collection of short fiction falls into an identifiable lineage of stories. There is no bombast, no ego, no fireworks. The formal limits of the short story are not challenged. Narrative time is, for the most part, linear. Characters and settings are drawn in the realist tradition. The narrative material is the stuff of Pākehā masculine legend; sport, sports injuries, work, possums, utes, parking tickets, and dads. The stories read like the yarns and tall tales published by male story writers in this country – Dan Davin, O.E. Middleton, Maurice Duggan – in the years following World War II.

Patchett’s sensibility, of course, is different to the post-war era writers. Here is a writer who is sensitive to a different atmosphere, and stories tuned to different expectations of men in our society. The male protagonists are active listeners, present fathers, and admiring husbands. They are not perfect, of course, but Patchett’s representation of male compassion is one many men might do well to aspire to: his characters offer a kind of salve to misogyny, rage and disconnection. Which is not to say the men of Have This Heart are heroic. They fail, and are flawed, but pathos is earned by their attempts to be better. They act against their silent, resistive, protective impulse to isolate themselves. These stories are infused with the sense that Pākehā men might do well to be more emotionally available members of their family, and of their community.

The titular story begins: ‘It had been a bad morning but now it was time to go out. The street and the few nasty places and then the park. Sally would help.’ Sally is a rescue dog recently adopted by Max. Exactly who is being rescued (and by whom) is up to the reader to decide. Max feels a fondness for Sally: ‘a strange hurting swell moved in his chest when he saw that she was among the best’ in the final Obedience Club examination. Could this ‘strange hurting swell’ be pride, relief, happiness, maybe even love? He does not explore further. Max’s avoidance of his emotions and their source is common for many of the men throughout the collection. They feel things, these men, and their inability to control or name the feeling provokes in them a fear response. Only the bravest will go searching for a solution, or, heaven forbid, ask for help.

What unifies this collection is Patchett’s sensitive rendering of the protagonists in each story. They are not the same man, but versions of a type. These men might be inarticulate, hurt, broken, in pain, struggling, or afraid, but Patchett’s compassionate approach to storytelling ensures they are given a fair hearing. Their stories reveal tender parts: a man who must forgive himself, a man out of his depth in the face of a crisis, an uncle protecting his niece and himself from bad news, and a grandfather who ‘made the school lunches every morning, a job he had taken on himself’. These unexpected depths might remain hidden in the hands of a less curious writer, or one less sensitive, less able to track how feelings extend not only through language, but through action and inaction. The way an impractical man enters a workshop, and ‘ducked his head despite the vast height of the roller door’, tells one protagonist a lot about this man’s character. We know the body houses emotion. Patchett recognises the body broadcasts emotion, too. His protagonists are especially tuned to the silent, physical world.

‘The European’, recognised in a shortlist for the Sargeson Prize, reads like a yarn. The narrator’s temperament is in stark contrast to that of his boss, Rob, who says things like, ‘Do you really think the spoiled twats who’re coming into this tent are going to care about linings, when they’ve come all this way to perv at these stupid fucking cars? Dickwad.’ After the narrator causes an accident that injures a new guy on their team, he checks in regularly on the young guy. ‘Well, sing out if you need anything’, he says. His constant checking is awkward, and at times cringeworthy, but it works to open the reader up to him. He knows he is being over cautious, a bit cloying. He recognises his own ‘sympathetic shit’ in the young man’s reluctant smile but carries on anyway because it is the right thing to do, or perhaps because he feels responsible. Motivations are complicated in these stories. This narrator, we learn, has a limit on his sense of responsibility.

In ‘Big Bastard’, set on a farm at night, the narrator’s silence carries as much emotion as what he reveals. Why can’t Evan sleep? Where is the mother of his children? What is keeping Evan’s own father awake at night? Why had ‘his dad’s guns finally been sent away?’ Of course, ‘Neither Evan nor his dad ever talked much about what woke and kept them from their beds each night.’ The next sentence is most telling. ‘No point.’ These are lonely men who care about each other, and are moved by each other’s presence, or absence, and whose relationship is almost entirely tacit. Theirs is a language forged by proximity. Evan recalls his father’s relationship with his sons, and ‘It broke your heart sometimes, Evan thought, how those boys handled their grandad, how they’d had to handle Evan himself’. How to propel a story whose telling events have already happened, or are happening in such subtle, almost imperceptible movements, is a difficult question. I said earlier that Patchett does not test the limits of the story, though, ‘Big Bastard’ does nudge of the reader’s expectations of a short story in subtle, almost imperceptible ways.

The first part of what I’m calling the Ōtautahi trilogy is ‘Lucky’, in which Marcus’s privilege is revealed by the story’s subversion of narrative expectations. ‘Half-time at the Roost’ is also set in Ōtautahi. A father, working as a journalist for a local paper, is photographing a rugby league match with his daughter, Emmy, and his dog, Sky. Again, the central tension of the story – Emmy’s mental health – hovers in the atmosphere. The narrator’s responsibility to his job, the league match, and the sense of being among a crowd are offered as the story’s subject, but really, they are a distraction from the father’s real concern, his daughter. Sky, another good dog, is a comfort. Although, as always, comfort works both ways. ‘‘It’s alright, boy,’ says Emmy. ‘They’re just excited.’ Sky tilts his head to take her pats, then shakes his ears when she stops. ‘You’re embarrassing him, Emmy,’ I say. ‘He likes to come across as a tough lone wolf when we come here.’

The third in the trilogy, ‘The Last Long Day’, is set in the shadow of the construction of Te Kaha, now known as One New Zealand Stadium. The atmosphere here is tense with disruption and impending displacement. Ben owns and operates a tool restoration business from a rented space set to be demolished in eighteen months-time, or so he thinks. Patchett nails the conversational tension between Ben, a practical, no-nonsense man, and Andrew, a younger man whose skill is apparently the art of making bad news palatable.

…‘How many kids have you got?’
…‘Two.’
…‘Nice, nice.’
…No kids yet, thought Ben. That’s what guys always said when they had nothing to offer about the world. He lifted the coffee press, hoping that the visitor had already drunk at Evie’s. ‘Black?’
…Again Andrew looked about the workshop, checking for a better alternative. ‘Black is good.’
…‘Good answer, I haven’t got any milk.’

The male protagonists in these stories appreciate straight talking. What they despise is misdirection, misunderstanding, overcomplication. They like a spade to be called a spade. They like plain, honest, direct conversations about practical, material things. Patchett, one feels, is also concerned with the way language can mislead, or misrepresent. In ‘The Newspaper Fella’, a local journalist, Hale Peckham, takes much care over a sentence about an injury to a local farmworker. His sentence must be both precise and vague. The sentence he goes with reads: ‘A farmworker sustained an injury at a Riverside address, by accidently directing a pick into his foot, and was taken to hospital late last week.’ Which appears innocuous enough, though the farmworker disagrees, the farmer is worried, and the story unravels the implications of reporting the news in small, rural communities. Everyone, it seems, will imagine their own story from the facts. For Hale, finding ‘the shame at a story’s centre always carried a small thrill.’

In ‘My Turn’ Patchett uses a dystopian future to write a story that reads like an allegory. A fire has broken out, and though David has a hi-vis vest, and once a month ‘knocked on doors in our row, making sure people knew my face and the agreed system for fighting fires and getting out safely’, he soon realises his temperament is ill-equipped to lead in a time of crisis. The person who takes over, ‘coming up with a new technique’ and ‘commanding those people’, should come as no surprise in a Patchett story. His narratives are filled with highly capable women who excel in all the ways that men lack. The few female characters in this collection are cast in a light that can only be described as one of admiration.

In his essay ‘On Writing’, Raymond Carver wrote that ‘a writer who has some special way of looking at things and who gives artistic expression to that way of looking: that writer may be around for a time.’ Patchett’s special way of looking at things is present in his body of work to date. What distinguishes his work, and is exemplified in this new collection of stories, is his gentle humanity. His is a sensitive, inclusive, and curious sensibility. This collection, his award-winning 2012 debut I Got His Blood on Me and his 2019 novel The Burning River all present a literary artistic project in which compassion and vigilance are presented as vital qualities for individual flourishing, and community cohesion.

Have This Heart

by Lawrence Patchett

Te Herenga Waka University Press

ISBN: 9781776923045

Published: May 2026

Format: Paperback, 212 pages

John Prins

John Prins is the author of the story collection Pastoral Care (Otago University Press, 2025). A graduate of the Master of Creative Writing programme at the University of Auckland, he is now studying for a PhD at the University of Otago.